By: Alan Good On: September 15, 2014 In: Blog, Features, Opinion Comments: 1

The three All-Ireland camogie finals were held in Croke Park on Sunday and proved to be a thorough afternoon’s entertainment.

There was admittedly Munster hockey interest, with SFH coach Katie Campbell (Catholic Institute, pictured below) lining out for Limerick in the intermediate decider while Orla Cotter (Fermoy, pictured below) scored 0-6 for Cork against a Kilkenny side featuring former UCC and Munster player Aine Connery in the senior decider.

I was at home nursing a dose of manflu, so kept one eye on Manchester United’s redemption against QPR and the other on the senior All-Ireland final. The latter was far more engrossing – another fine exhibition of women’s sport in a year that has thankfully seen it get more attention than usual via the exploits of the Irish women’s rugby team.


Unfortunately, there were only 15,000 people there to see it. That’s a lot of empty seats in an 82,000-seater stadium that was full for Kilkenny’s epic drawn All-Ireland senior hurling championship final against Tipperary, and will be chockers again for the replay and the men’s football final between Donegal and Kerry.

There’s a chicken-and-egg argument that underpins all this of course, and it isn’t my intention to re-hash it here; Derval O’Rourke’s Irish Examiner column did a good job of summarising the issues surrounding coverage and promotion of women’s sport. But Sport For Business ran a fine piece about why the camogie finals both deserved and should have had a bigger audience and it got me thinking.

“The opportunity to see sport at the highest level is what inspires young people to pick up a ball and kick, puck or throw in their back gardens and parks throughout the rest of the year,” they wrote. “It’s a chance to open eyes to what can be achieved by continuing to go to training on cold nights in November.”

They added that members of Dublin’s 50 camogie clubs “could and should have been at Croke Park yesterday to see what their game can deliver for them” before concluding that “if you don’t see the magic, you can’t be inspired by the magic”.

Anyone who attended the 2012 Olympic qualifiers in Dublin (pictured below) will understand this. The point is also instructional for Munster hockey, where attendances at senior club games have dwindled significantly over the past 10 years.


Every year we have some superb hockey being played on our doorsteps in the Irish Senior Cup and Irish Hockey League, but only at the senior schools cup finals, or when an U16 or U18 interpros is held in Cork, do we get reasonable supporter numbers of elite hockey – mainly due to schoolchildren coming to support their friends.

There were about three times as many people at the 2013 women’s Division 5 Cup final between UCC and Cork Wanderers than attended either of the Munster Senior Cup finals that year, as both clubs galvanised friends and family to come watch.

While it is true that the majority of players learn by doing rather than watching, it never hurts to go and see what is possible in our sport and be inspired by watching Munster’s best do their stuff, especially when the top sides from around the country come to town.

As a coach I routinely tell schools players to go and watch the highest senior adult team in their club and “player cam” whoever is playing in their position, as opposed to just watching passively. I ask them to look at their subject’s positioning, the decisions they make, how they communicate on the pitch, and come back and tell me what they’ve noticed or learned.

To date, not one player has taken me up on this.

You can’t force anyone to go and watch a match, but hockey is missing a trick here. Aspiring rugby players can go watch Munster in Thomond Park, soccer fans have a handful of Airtricity League teams in the province’s big cities. Both sports have endless amounts of top-class exhibitions of their games on television.

Having the Hockey World Cup on Sky Sports certainly helped matters this summer, but for those of us who play this beautiful game, more effort is required. The Division 1 leagues get underway this weekend; get out and support your first team this season, you might just learn something.


    • Diane Haly Buckley
    • September 19, 2014

    Dear Alan ,
    Fantastic writing ! powerful article …..
    I am going to print your article off and give it to all my U16s on Sunday morning up at training in Harlequins .
    I am going to sit them all down in a group and read it out to them and discuss ….
    I have been trying to relay the same message to girls for over 15 years now and somehow nothing changes……..only the wise few get that its through watching games , not just hockey games but soccer, camoige , rugby etc that women will get a better understanding of sport , of being creative , being decisive , being ambitious and rising above their own expectations of their own game .
    Unfortunately as parents we don’t give out the same message to our girls as we do to our boys …….we encourage our boys to do it all , to aim very high but with our girls its a case of … cant do it all …..make your choices but …..your schooling has to come first … somewhere after ……
    That’s where the greatest challenge lies ……..
    As a parent of 4 very active sporting girls ,Im proud to say i have managed to keep that balance for my girls between achieving in school and in sport , it requires plenty of discipline, lots of sacrifices but the rewards are enormous …..Balanced kids with the belief that you can do it all !
    Thanks for drawing our attention to the need to support women in sport and thanks for caring .
    Yours in Sport

Leave reply:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *