A player eligibility issue involving defending Irish Senior Cup champions Pembroke Wanderers threatens to overshadow the Dubliners’ quest to retain the trophy when they lock horns with Cookstown at Belfield on Sunday (1.15pm).
The Irish Hockey Association (IHA) yesterday moved to clarify a query from Mossley regarding the registration of Pembroke’s South African import, Vaughan Erasmus, who played and scored in the latter’s 6-0 quarter-final win at The Glade on February 28.
While Erasmus was seemingly correctly registered with both the IHA and the Leinster Branch in time, visa complications delayed his arrival from November until January.
Pembroke's Vaughan Erasmus is at the centre of an eligibility controversy. Picture: Adrian Boehm
Under strict interpretation of the rules, Erasmus was not eligible to participate in national competitions as he had not played for his club prior to December 31 last year – despite, according to an IHA statement released yesterday, “intending” to do so. He has not subsequently appeared for Pembroke on the national stage.
However, the statement revealed that Pembroke will not suffer any sanctions, claiming that Erasmus’ appearance against Mossley “was deemed to have been an unintentional and genuine error”. The body also admitted that Pembroke’s decision to play him was “in part due to a miscommunication with clubs by the IHA around player eligibility”.
Erasmus is not eligible to pay for any Irish competition for the remainder of the season – ruling him out of Sunday’s final and the Irish Hockey League semi-final clash with Three Rock Rovers next weekend.
The IHA has pledged to undertake “a full review of the regulations regarding registration and eligibility of players for Irish competitions” prior to next season.
Nonetheless, the issue is sure to be hotly debated among rank and file members of the sport’s community over the coming weeks.
Pembroke will nonetheless be trying not to be distracted by the off-pitch furore as they look to quell the challenge of a Cookstown side who are contesting the ISC final for the first time in 22 years. Ireland’s recent EuroHockey rankings boost means a place in next season’s EuroHockey League is at stake for the winner.
The Serpentine Avenue outfit have been in ruthless form in recent weeks, reclaiming the Leinster league and annexing the EuroHockey Club Trophy, and will be favourites on paper.
Despite a suspicion that Cookstown are somewhat vulnerable away from their Coolnafranky base, they are not Ulster champions for nothing and have mercurial Ulster U21 captain David Ames back in harness following an elbow injury.
Munster U21 captain Roger Gray will be a key figure as Cork C of I go in search of a first Irish Junior Cup win since 2003. Picture: Adrian Boehm
Meanwhile, UCD will look to continue their giant-killing exploits as they look to add to their sole women’s ISC success 58 years ago. Mary Logue’s students will have home advantage for Sunday’s final (3.30pm) and have already seen off Hermes, Loreto and Ulster Elks along the way, and will have members of the 1951 vintage in the stand to lend their support.
But standing in their way are Belfast powerhouses Pegasus, who are gunning for a three-in-a-row. UCD must quell what is arguably the country’s most dangerous forward trio – Claire McMahon, Alex Speers and Suzanne Beaney – if they are to pull off another major upset.
The Irish Junior Cups are also down for decision, with Pembroke’s men chasing a senior and junior double.
Their seconds meet Cork C of I (tomorrow, 2pm), who have disposed of Annadale, Cork Harlequins, Cookstown and Glenanne en route to the final, and for whom two players will be looking to roll back the years in style.
Derek Hales and Richie Dorman were part of the last C of I side to win this competition, with a 1-0 win over Lisnagarvey in 1993. Dorman’s last-gasp winner helped them see off Cookstown 4-3 in the last four, and he will be hoping to repeat the feat to help Dermot Judge’s side bridge a 16-year gap.
The women’s competition has been dominated by Leinster sides this term, with the eastern province providing all four of the semi-finalists.
Hermes and Railway Union who have progressed to the decider, with the latter favourites to end a 32-year famine based on league form, where they topped Leinster’s Division Two, 12 points ahead of sixth-placed Hermes.
But the majority of attention in Munster will turn to Harlequin Park on Sunday (1pm), where UCC bid to end Cork Harlequins’ 13-year stranglehold on the Munster women’s title.
The sides finished locked on 36 points in the regular league campaign after College pulled off a thrilling last-day 4-3 win over Quins, forcing a title playoff.
Rachael Kohler will be marked absent as Quins put their Munster title on the line against UCC. Picture: Adrian Boehm
Fiona O’Connell is out for UCC with a sprained ankle, while Rachael Kohler, Jane Chapple and Cliona O’Connor will again miss out for Quins due to personal reasons.
SaturdayMen’s Irish Junior Cup final: Pembroke Wanderers vs Cork C of I (Belfield, 2pm)
Women’s ESB Irish Junior Cup final: Hermes vs Railway Union (Belfield, 4.15pm)
SundayMen’s Irish Senior Cup final: Pembroke Wanderers vs Cookstown (Belfield, 1.15pm)
Women’s ESB Irish Senior Cup final: Pegasus vs UCD (Belfield, 3.30pm)
Women’s Div 1 title playoff: Cork Harlequins vs UCC (1pm)
Men’s Barber Cup final: Belvedere B vs UCC C (Harlequin Park, 3pm)
Post Author:
alangood
7 Replies to “Pembroke escape sanction amid Erasmus elibigility row”
was it ucc that won the league before quins went on the 13 yr winning streak?
Pembroke broke the rules and should be disqualified.Very harsh but thats the way it is.Bending the rules will cause more problems than it solves .
Seems a little odd to schedule the play off for the same day as the ISC.
The mistake of playing Erazmus is irrelevant, Pembroke broke the rules. The management board of the IHA reiterated the rule of ineligibility of Erazmus by saying
that he ‘is not eligible to play for Pembroke in any Irish competition for the remainder of the season’. If he is not eligible now how was he eligible then ? The management board have bottled it by not implementing the rules and disqualifying
Pembroke. Unfortunately, Pembroke should be disqualified, otherwise throw away the rule book!
Pembroke break the rules but stay in the competition.What a complete joke!
God what a farce! Talk about a cop out by the IHA.
If anyone should be challenging this decision it should be Glenanne after the Alan Lewis ruling. Mossley must also have a good case to challenge this. What is the point in having the elegibility rules (which are clearly stated on the website and circulated to all clubs) if they allow Pembroke to get off scot free in this case?
In all cases it is the responsibility of the club involved to ensure that all of their players are correctly registered according to the regulations so the IHA comments about miscommunication are totally irrelevant.
One rule for Pembroke….
Pembroke broke a rule and should be disqualified.Its as simple as that.The IHA have admitted that they broke a rule.What’s the problem?Apply the rules or tear up the rule book altogether!!!
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Privacy Overview
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
was it ucc that won the league before quins went on the 13 yr winning streak?
Pembroke broke the rules and should be disqualified.Very harsh but thats the way it is.Bending the rules will cause more problems than it solves .
Seems a little odd to schedule the play off for the same day as the ISC.
The mistake of playing Erazmus is irrelevant, Pembroke broke the rules. The management board of the IHA reiterated the rule of ineligibility of Erazmus by saying
that he ‘is not eligible to play for Pembroke in any Irish competition for the remainder of the season’. If he is not eligible now how was he eligible then ? The management board have bottled it by not implementing the rules and disqualifying
Pembroke. Unfortunately, Pembroke should be disqualified, otherwise throw away the rule book!
Pembroke break the rules but stay in the competition.What a complete joke!
God what a farce! Talk about a cop out by the IHA.
If anyone should be challenging this decision it should be Glenanne after the Alan Lewis ruling. Mossley must also have a good case to challenge this. What is the point in having the elegibility rules (which are clearly stated on the website and circulated to all clubs) if they allow Pembroke to get off scot free in this case?
In all cases it is the responsibility of the club involved to ensure that all of their players are correctly registered according to the regulations so the IHA comments about miscommunication are totally irrelevant.
One rule for Pembroke….
Pembroke broke a rule and should be disqualified.Its as simple as that.The IHA have admitted that they broke a rule.What’s the problem?Apply the rules or tear up the rule book altogether!!!